Printify
vs
Gelato Gelato is cheaper on 7 in 10 products both sell.
We priced the same products at both, delivered to the US with shipping. Gelato came out cheaper on 67 of 102, and paid plans don't change that. Printify keeps canvas, and Australia on free plans.
US delivery · free plans · 102 products both sell
67 cheaper at Gelato by a typical $2.85
34 cheaper at Printify by a typical $2.03
1 costs the same at both
1 product costs the same at both.
US delivery · category by category
Every product both sell, one square each. A product can sit in two categories, like an organic hoodie in eco-friendly and hoodies.
Sweatshirts 15 products Gelato 15 of 15
Eco-friendly 22 products Gelato 19 of 22
Hoodies 15 products Gelato 10 of 15
Typical shipping on these three: $8.79 at Printify, $7.39 at Gelato.
Typical shipping on these three: $8.79 at Printify, $7.39 at Gelato.
Gelato's typical sweatshirt also costs $27.49 before shipping, against Printify's $31.68.
Hats 4 products Gelato 3 · Printify 1
Typical hat shipping: $5.04 at Printify, $3.99 at Gelato.
Typical hat shipping: $5.04 at Printify, $3.99 at Gelato.
Long sleeves 5 products Gelato 5 of 5
Shipping is level. The typical long sleeve costs $20.20 at Gelato, $22.32 at Printify.
T-shirts 46 products Printify 23 · Gelato 22
The closest call: 1 tee costs the same at both.
The closest call. A typical tee costs $15.90 at Printify and $15.16 at Gelato, plus $4.95 and $4.99 shipping.
Canvas prints 3 products Printify 3 of 3
Printify's typical canvas costs $18.50 before shipping; Gelato's $33.29.
Printify's typical canvas costs $18.50 before shipping. Gelato's costs $33.29.
US delivery · the widest gaps
Delivered price on each dot; product plus shipping underneath.
Gelato's widest wins
Econscious EC5500 hoodie Gelato $13.48 less
Gelato $13.48 less Printify's price from Fulfill Engine
Gelato $40.58: $33.19 + $7.39 shipping Printify $54.06: $43.67 + $10.39 shipping, via Fulfill Engine
Independent Trading Co. PRM3500 Pigment-Dyed Crewneck · Sweatshirts Sweatshirts Gelato $13.19 less
Gelato $13.19 less Printify's price from Ink Blot
Gelato $42.23: $34.84 + $7.39 shipping Printify $55.42: $45.03 + $10.39 shipping, via Ink Blot
Printify's widest wins
Canvas print Printify $14.19 less
Printify $14.19 less Printify's price from Roma Imaging
Printify $30.99: $18.50 + $12.49 shipping, via Roma Imaging Gelato $45.18: $33.29 + $11.89 shipping
AS Colour 5051 Basic Tee · T-shirts T-shirts Printify $8.52 less
Printify $8.52 less Printify's price from Printify Choice
Printify $24.31: $19.36 + $4.95 shipping, via Printify Choice Gelato $32.83: $27.84 + $4.99 shipping
US delivery · who makes it
Printify is a marketplace of independent print providers. You pick one, let Order Routing switch, or let Printify Choice decide, and another provider can change the price and delivery time. Our 102 US prices come from 9 of them.
Gelato picks a partner printer for each order. You can't choose the printer or the country.
Printify Choice 23 of 60 cheaper at Printify
Fulfill Engine 2 of 18 cheaper at Printify
SwiftPOD 1 of 7 cheaper at Printify
Monster Digital 2 of 5 cheaper at Printify
5 more providers · 12 products
Roma Imaging: 3 of 3 cheaper at Printify, all canvas
Ink Blot 0 of 3 · Printful 1 of 3 · Dimona Tee 1 of 2 · Stakes Manufacturing 1 of 1
US delivery · three staples, line by line
The hoodie is one of Printify's 34 wins, and Printful makes it. The hoodie is one of Printify's 34 wins, and Printful makes it. Gelato takes the tee and the mug.
Printify via Printify Choice · 3–7 business days
$11.29 + $4.95 shipping = $16.24
$11.29 + $4.95 = $16.24
3–7 business days
Gelato partner network · 4–6 business days
$10.69 + $4.99 shipping = $15.68
$10.69 + $4.99 = $15.68
4–6 business days
Gelato's tee costs $0.60 less; its shipping costs $0.04 more.
$0.56 cheaper at Gelato. Its tee costs $0.60 less; its shipping $0.04 more.
$0.56 cheaper at Gelato
Printify made by Printful · 3–7 business days
$19.86 + $8.79 shipping = $28.65
$19.86 + $8.79 = $28.65
3–7 business days
Gelato partner network · 4–6 business days
$21.59 + $7.39 shipping = $28.98
$21.59 + $7.39 = $28.98
4–6 business days
Printify's hoodie costs $1.73 less; its shipping costs $1.40 more.
$0.33 cheaper at Printify. Its hoodie costs $1.73 less; its shipping $1.40 more.
$0.33 cheaper at Printify
Printify via Printify Choice · 4–8 business days
$5.83 + $7.29 shipping = $13.12
$5.83 + $7.29 = $13.12
4–8 business days
Gelato partner network · 5–6 business days
$6.26 + $6.49 shipping = $12.75
$6.26 + $6.49 = $12.75
5–6 business days
Gelato's shipping costs $0.80 less; its mug costs $0.43 more.
$0.37 cheaper at Gelato. Its shipping costs $0.80 less; its mug $0.43 more.
$0.37 cheaper at Gelato
Try it
Switch the country or compare Printify Premium with Gelato+. Same supplier quotes as the charts above.
Print provider: Printify Choice
Product + shipping
$16.24
Checked Oct 28, 2026Printify page
Made by Gelato
Product + shipping
$15.68
Checked Oct 28, 2026Gelato page
Same product, size and color at both. Another Printify print provider may price it differently.
Compare every supplier for the Bella+Canvas 3001 →Five countries · free and paid plans
Local currency, checked Oct 28, 2026. Paid compares Printify Premium ($39 a month) with Gelato+ ($29.99 a month). Each country in its own currency, checked Oct 28, 2026. Paid compares Printify Premium ($39 a month) with Gelato+ ($29.99 a month).
United States 102 products · 1 same price
Free: Printify 34 · Gelato 67 · same 1 Paid: Printify 34 · Gelato 68
Canada 103 products
Free: Printify 31 · Gelato 72 Paid: Printify 31 · Gelato 72
United Kingdom 33 products
Free: Printify 11 · Gelato 22 Paid: Printify 9 · Gelato 24
Germany 36 products
Free: Printify 16 · Gelato 20 Paid: Printify 13 · Gelato 23
Australia · flips with Gelato+ 32 products
Free: Printify 21 · Gelato 11 Paid: Printify 15 · Gelato 17
Australia turns on product price
Australia turns on product price: Printify's typical product costs A$24.78 there, Gelato's A$26.93. On free plans Printify's typical product costs A$24.78 there, against Gelato's A$26.93, so Printify leads 21 to 11. Put Printify Premium against Gelato+ and Gelato leads 17 to 15.
Shipping still favors Gelato abroad
Shipping still favors Gelato abroad: a typical hoodie ships for A$12.50 against A$32.92 to Australia and £4.48 against £6.70 to the UK. Printify's typical hoodie shipping is A$32.92 to Australia and £6.70 to the UK. Gelato's is A$12.50 and £4.48.
Short answers
How they work
Each answer links to the supplier page it comes from. Checked August 9 to October 20, 2026.
Printify: An independent print provider. You pick one, let Order Routing switch, or let Printify Choice decide.
Gelato: A partner printer Gelato picks for each order. You can't choose the printer or the country.
Both: Etsy, Shopify and WooCommerce
Printify: Plus Amazon and eBay, for US sellers.
Gelato: Plus Wix, Squarespace and BigCommerce.
Printify: US shops only
Gelato: US and UK shops
Printify: Insert cards from $0.25 an order and neck labels from $0.55, where the provider offers them.
Gelato: Printed neck labels on supported tees. Insert cards and parcel labels on some posters, with Gelato+.
Printify: Premium takes up to 20% off most products.
Gelato: Gelato+ takes up to 33% off eligible products for delivery to its listed countries, with no discount on shipping.
Same at both: your store takes payment, and you answer buyers and decide refunds. The supplier makes and ships the order and handles claims about its own production faults.