Gelato vs Prodigi

Gelato for US buyers. Prodigi for the UK and Australia.

Two wall-art specialists, priced on the same products with shipping. Gelato is cheaper on 19 of 27 for US buyers. Prodigi is cheaper on 10 of 14 for Australian buyers and 10 of 17 in the UK.

Compare your product →

Same print, two countries

Fine art print, giclée

12 × 16 in, portrait · one print plus shipping

United States

Gelato $16.65

$11.75 print + $4.90 shipping

Prodigi $23.85

$12.00 print + $11.85 shipping

Gelato $7.20 cheaper

United Kingdom

Gelato £15.01

£10.33 print + £4.68 shipping

Prodigi £11.60

£6.00 print + £5.60 shipping

Prodigi £3.41 cheaper

Every product both sell, not just prints

US · 27 compared Gelato 19 · Prodigi 8

Gelato 19 · Prodigi 8

UK · 17 compared Gelato 7 · Prodigi 10

Gelato 7 · Prodigi 10
One item plus shipping, on free plans. The print was checked Oct 28 at Gelato and Oct 28 at Prodigi; US prices checked Oct 28, 2026.

Wall art, side by side · one piece plus shipping

Gelato sweeps wall art in the US. Prodigi sweeps it in Germany.

The same four 12 × 16 pieces, priced in five countries. Prodigi charges $22.00 to ship a canvas to the US; Gelato charges $11.89. Gelato takes three of four in the UK, Prodigi takes three of four in Australia, and Canada split two each.

Each cell shows the delivered total, then product + shipping, in local currency on free plans.

Fine art print Giclée

Gelato 3 · Prodigi 2
US

Gelato $11.75 + $4.90 $16.65

Prodigi $12.00 + $11.85 $23.85

Canada

Gelato CA$24.49 + CA$8.97 CA$33.46

Prodigi CA$11.22 + CA$26.10 CA$37.32

UK

Gelato £10.33 + £4.68 £15.01

Prodigi £6.00 + £5.60 £11.60

Germany

Gelato €11.98 + €7.02 €19.00

Prodigi €7.00 + €6.75 €13.75

Australia

Gelato A$18.76 + A$11.52 A$30.28

Prodigi A$17.93 + A$13.94 A$31.87

Canvas 12 × 16 in

Gelato 2 · Prodigi 3
US

Gelato $33.29 + $11.89 $45.18

Prodigi $26.00 + $22.00 $48.00

Canada

Gelato CA$52.02 + CA$22.43 CA$74.45

Prodigi CA$36.39 + CA$25.12 CA$61.51

UK

Gelato £18.97 + £5.80 £24.77

Prodigi £19.00 + £7.85 £26.85

Germany

Gelato €24.07 + €9.28 €33.35

Prodigi €22.00 + €6.95 €28.95

Australia

Gelato A$53.86 + A$16.42 A$70.28

Prodigi A$46.00 + A$12.95 A$58.95

Thin canvas 12 × 16 in

Gelato 2 · Prodigi 3
US

Gelato $24.89 + $11.89 $36.78

Prodigi $18.00 + $22.00 $40.00

Canada

Gelato CA$41.20 + CA$22.43 CA$63.63

Prodigi CA$32.19 + CA$25.12 CA$57.31

UK

Gelato £15.09 + £5.80 £20.89

Prodigi £17.00 + £9.95 £26.95

Germany

Gelato €18.55 + €9.28 €27.83

Prodigi €19.00 + €6.95 €25.95

Australia

Gelato A$41.40 + A$16.42 A$57.82

Prodigi A$44.00 + A$12.95 A$56.95

Framed canvas 12 × 16 in

Gelato 3 · Prodigi 2
US

Gelato $47.03 + $9.49 $56.52

Prodigi $44.00 + $24.80 $68.80

Canada

Gelato CA$78.96 + CA$18.65 CA$97.61

Prodigi CA$88.17 + CA$27.15 CA$115.32

UK

Gelato £29.66 + £8.08 £37.74

Prodigi £33.00 + £7.85 £40.85

Germany

Gelato €52.25 + €8.56 €60.81

Prodigi €48.00 + €9.70 €57.70

Australia

Gelato A$84.14 + A$26.20 A$110.34

Prodigi A$56.62 + A$14.99 A$71.61

Every product both sell · five countries

Gelato leads in the US and Canada. Prodigi leads in the UK, Germany and Australia.

Bars run out from the middle: left for products cheaper at Gelato, right for Prodigi. Paid compares Gelato+ with Prodigi Pro, which flips Germany to Gelato. Shipping is the median on the tees and wall art both sell.

United States

27 compared

Gelato Prodigi Cheaper, free plans 19 8 Cheaper, paid plans 22 5 Shipping a tee $4.99 $10.75 Shipping wall art $10.69 $22.00

Canada

14 compared

Gelato Prodigi Cheaper, free plans 9 5 Cheaper, paid plans 10 4 Shipping a tee CA$13.16 CA$21.18 Shipping wall art CA$20.54 CA$26.10

United Kingdom

17 compared

Gelato Prodigi Cheaper, free plans 7 10 Cheaper, paid plans 8 9 Shipping a tee £3.25 £2.25 Shipping wall art £5.80 £7.85

Germany Paid plans flip it

17 compared

Gelato Prodigi Cheaper, free plans 7 10 Cheaper, paid plans 9 8 Shipping a tee €4.28 €3.80 Shipping wall art €8.92 €6.95

Australia

14 compared

Gelato Prodigi Cheaper, free plans 4 10 Cheaper, paid plans 5 9 Shipping a tee A$13.15 A$6.66 Shipping wall art A$15.34 A$14.47

Branding on wall art · from each supplier's own pages

Branding a canvas order? Only Prodigi can, and without a paid plan.

Both ship in plain packaging. What each can add to the parcel depends on the product, and on where it's made.

Gelato

Sources ↗

  • T-shirts Printed neck labels on supported tees.

  • Posters An insert card and a parcel label, with Gelato+ only.

  • Canvas and mugs No inserts or labels.

Prodigi

Sources ↗

  • Canvas and framed art Inserts, stickers and colour packing slips on pieces from its own labs. No plan needed; Prodigi Pro takes 75% off inserts.

  • Apparel and mugs No inserts or labels.

Three orders up close · US delivery · free plans

Apparel splits too: tees go to Gelato, hoodies to Prodigi.

Prodigi charges $10.75 to ship a tee to the US against Gelato's $4.99, but ships a hoodie for $6.75 against $7.39. In all three orders below, the cheaper supplier charges less for both the product and the shipping.

US t-shirts cheaper at Gelato
10 of 10
US hoodies cheaper at Prodigi
4 of 4

T-shirt · Adult M · Black

Bella+Canvas 3001

Gelato $15.68

$10.69 product + $4.99 shipping · 4–6 business days

Prodigi $22.75

$12.00 product + $10.75 shipping · 3–8 business days

Gelato $7.07 cheaper

Checked Oct 28 at Gelato, Oct 28 at Prodigi, 2026

Hoodie · Adult M · Black

Gildan 18500 hoodie

Gelato $28.98

$21.59 product + $7.39 shipping · 4–6 business days

Prodigi $25.75

$19.00 product + $6.75 shipping · 4–9 business days

Prodigi $3.23 cheaper

Checked Oct 28 at Gelato, Oct 28 at Prodigi, 2026

Wall art · 12" x 16" · Portrait · Giclee

Fine art print

Gelato $16.65

$11.75 product + $4.90 shipping · 2–5 business days

Prodigi $23.85

$12.00 product + $11.85 shipping · 6–8 business days

Gelato $7.20 cheaper

Checked Oct 28 at Gelato, Oct 28 at Prodigi, 2026

Try it

Check your product, country and plan

Prices come from the same supplier quotes as the tables above.

Deliver to
Plan
Shown for Adult M · Black

Gelato

Made by Gelato

$7.07 lower

Product + shipping

$15.68

Product
$10.69
Shipping
$4.99
Delivery
4–6 business days
Duty (separate)
$0.00

Checked Oct 28, 2026Gelato page

Prodigi

Made by Prodigi

Product + shipping

$22.75

Product
$12.00
Shipping
$10.75
Delivery
3–8 business days
Duty (separate)
$0.00

Checked Oct 28, 2026Prodigi page

Same product, size and color at both.

Compare every supplier for the Bella+Canvas 3001 →

What sellers ask

Gelato or Prodigi: the short answers

Is Gelato or Prodigi cheaper?
For US buyers, Gelato: cheaper on 19 of the 27 products both sell, counting product and shipping. For Australian buyers, Prodigi: 10 of 14. US prices checked October 28, 2026.
Which is cheaper for wall art?
In the US, Gelato on all four 12 × 16 pieces; in Germany, Prodigi on all four. A fine art print costs $16.65 delivered from Gelato and $23.85 from Prodigi in the US.
Which is cheaper for t-shirts?
Gelato, on 10 of the 10 t-shirts both sell for US delivery. On the Bella+Canvas 3001 it's $7.07 cheaper: $15.68 delivered against $22.75.
Does a paid plan change who's cheaper?
In the US it widens Gelato's lead: comparing Gelato+ with Prodigi Pro, Prodigi is cheaper on 5 of 27 products instead of 8. In Germany it flips the lead to Gelato, 9 to 8.
Which one delivers faster?
Gelato quotes 2–5 business days for the fine art print against Prodigi's 6–8. For the tee 4–6 against 3–8, and for the hoodie 4–6 against 4–9.
Can I brand a canvas order?
With Prodigi, yes: canvas and framed art from its own labs can carry inserts, stickers and colour packing slips, with no plan needed. Gelato adds nothing to canvas.

How they work · from each supplier's own pages

Both choose where your order is made. Only Prodigi shows you first.

Each answer links to the supplier page it comes from. Inserts and labels are covered in the branding section above. Checked August 9 to October 21, 2026.

Who makes the order

Sources ↗

Gelato A confidential partner network. Gelato picks the site; you can't choose a country or partner.

Prodigi Prodigi's own and partner labs, picked by product and destination. Its quote API shows the country first.

TikTok Shop

Sources ↗

Gelato US and UK shops

Prodigi UK shops only

API and bulk orders

Sources ↗

Gelato REST API and webhooks. Manual orders without a store.

Prodigi API with a free test sandbox, CSV bulk orders, and a hold to edit before production.

Same at both

Sources ↗

Your buyers, on your own store

You take payment, answer buyers and set returns. Neither takes unwanted returns; each fixes its own errors.

Etsy, Shopify and WooCommerce

All three connect directly, and orders are fulfilled automatically.